Sunday, January 29, 2012

What do these have in common?

What do a single family home and a drugstore in the bottom of a church have in common? Read on!

One day I was reading the local newspaper on-line and noticed an article about the houses being renovated on Race Street. One in particular caught my eye since it looked like a single family home instead of the usual tenement.

I started with the Sanborn Insurance Maps and this told me the address was 509 Race Street prior to the city-wide renumbering that took place in 1895-96. This gave me the information I needed to start searching the city directories for a name.
"1875 - MUELLER C. H., Druggist and Apothecary,s. w. c. Race and 15th; Residence, 509 Race"

Charles H. Mueller actually started as a "Druggist and Apothecary" as earlier as 1868 at the southwest corner of Race and 15th. If we take a look at a map:
1887 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map - Source

 ... we see that at that same location is St. Paul's German Evangelical Church. In the following map from 1891, it is clearly marked that this location says "drugs".
1891 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map - Source
What the heck is a drugstore doing at the street level of a church? Apparently, this retail space was built in order to support the church with consistent income to help pay off the construction costs. Charles Mueller ran his pharmacy (he is listed as a pharmacist starting in 1895) at this location starting in 1868, with his son, Oscar, joining him in 1900. 

It remained their business and 509 Race was their home from approximately 1875 until Charles' death in 1919. Afterward, it was occupied by various families, mainly of Italian descent. The home is being renovated as part of the Park Haus project through 3CDC.
The church has also had some recent stabilization work completed and 3CDC is looking into options for its reuse.
2011 by cincyhistoryluvr
Just another great example of how Over-the-Rhine was a neighborhood where the German immigrants lived, worked and played!


  1. Hi Cincy History Lover - Just thought you might be interested to know, we will soon be owners of 1419 Race Street. Thanks for the information, my husband has been doing some of the same research. We love the history of the home!

    1. Annette - I am so glad you saw this! I was hoping you would. I can send you the information I have and also pull the Census records. Just send me an e-mail if you are interested.

      I would love to see before and afters of the house too, if you are willing to share.

  2. Love the idea behind this blog. Keep up the great work? Would you be interested in a collaboration sometime?

  3. I believe the corner shop was a drug store well into more "modern" times. For quite a while, the remains of an orange metal "Rexall Drugs" sign hung on the exterior, only removed when 3CDC started doing work.


These comments are moderated before published. If you are trying to reach the author of this blog, use the Contact Us form to the right.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.